FrothierFrothier All races →

New York 17 House race 2026: Conley vs. Lawler polls

Updated November 21, 2026 · Election day has passed

Cait Conley (D) and Mike Lawler (R) are running for the House seat in New York 17. Across 3 polls, the Frothier average has Cait Conley at 47.9% and Mike Lawler at 46.8%, which is Conley +1.1. That gives Cait Conley a 53% chance of winning, and the race is rated Toss-up.

Race called
Cait Conley (D) won.
Conley flips this seat from Republican to Democrat, a net gain of one for Democrats in the House.
Rating
Toss-up
Set by the win estimate
Chance of winning
53%
Cait Conley (D)
Polling average
Conley +1.1
3 polls, newest Sep 30
Frothier estimate
Conley +0.6
Give or take 7.9 points
Heads up: the newest poll in this race ended on September 30, 52 days ago. Until new polls come in, treat the average as a rough guide.

About this race

This is the race for New York’s 17th congressional district in the U.S. House of Representatives. Voters decide it on Tuesday, November 3, 2026.

Frothier has found 3 general-election polls of this race, and the newest ended on September 30.

Where the race stands

Cait ConleyDemocrat
47.9%
Mike LawlerRepublican
46.8%
Chance of winning
Conley 53%Lawler 47%

How the polls have moved

The polling average over the last four months. Above the middle line Conley leads; below it Lawler leads.

D+5EvenR+5Jul 6Nov 3

Recent polls

Newest first. Polls paid for by a party or a campaign are tagged and count for half in the average.

PollsterEndedSampleConley (D)Lawler (R)Margin
McLaughlin & AssociatesR poll Sep 30400 LV 47.050.0Lawler +3.0
Emerson College Sep 29400 LV 47.945.6Conley +2.3
co/efficient Jul 221,292 LV 45.050.0Lawler +5.0
FM3 ResearchD poll Jul 1509 LV 51.045.0Conley +6.0

Frothier coverage

Recent stories from the outlets Frothier tracks that name these candidates.

Compare with other trackers

See how other poll trackers read this race. These links open their sites in a new tab.

Questions about this race

When is the New York 17 House race 2026?

Election Day is Tuesday, November 3, 2026.

Who is running in the New York 17 House race?

Frothier tracks Cait Conley (Democrat) against Mike Lawler (Republican).

Who is leading the New York 17 House race polls?

Cait Conley +1.1 in the Frothier average of 3 polls (Cait Conley 47.9%, Mike Lawler 46.8%), as of November 21, 2026.

Who is favored to win the New York 17 House race?

Frothier rates the race Toss-up. Cait Conley has about a 53% chance of winning. That is a probability, not a call.

How recent are the New York 17 House race polls?

The newest poll ended on September 30, 2026. That is more than six weeks old, so the average may not show where the race stands today.

How this estimate is made

Every general-election poll goes into one weighted average: newer, larger and likely-voter polls count for more, and no single pollster can flood it. House district estimates use polls alone, so they carry more uncertainty than statewide races. A win estimate is a probability, not a call: a candidate with a 70 percent chance loses three times in ten. Full method and sources.

Poll data from The New York Times poll database, CC BY 4.0, via PollResults.org. Averages, ratings and projections are Frothier calculations.

More races

New York governor
Safe D
New York 21 House
Tilt R
New York 23 House
Safe R
North Carolina 11 House
Toss-up
Pennsylvania 1 House
Toss-up
Ohio 10 House
Toss-up
Minnesota 1 House
Toss-up
Missouri 2 House
Toss-up
Ohio 15 House
Toss-up
Pennsylvania 10 House
Toss-up
Texas 35 House
Toss-up
Colorado 5 House
Toss-up
See the full election tracker →